In a heated post-game analysis following the Indiana Fever’s narrow 90-88 defeat to the New York Liberty on May 24, 2025, ESPN analyst Monica McNutt once again found herself at the center of controversy for her pointed criticism of Fever star Caitlin Clark. The game, which saw the Liberty remain unbeaten, was marked by a controversial no-call in the final seconds, sparking debate among fans and analysts alike. McNutt’s remarks, which focused on Clark’s performance and decision-making, have reignited discussions about her ongoing scrutiny of the WNBA’s rising star.
The Fever, led by Clark’s high-octane offensive play, battled fiercely against the reigning champions at Gainbridge Fieldhouse. Despite a valiant effort, the game’s closing moments proved decisive. With 2.2 seconds remaining, Clark attempted a game-winning 3-pointer but was stripped by Liberty guard Natasha Cloud, prompting Clark to plead for a foul that never came. The non-call left Clark and the Fever frustrated, as they believed it cost them a chance to tie or win the game. Clark, who finished with 18 points, 10 assists, and a career-high 10 turnovers, struggled with efficiency, particularly from beyond the arc, where she went 0-for-7.
McNutt, known for her candid takes, didn’t hold back on ESPN’s post-game coverage. She argued that Clark’s turnovers were a critical factor in the Fever’s loss, pointing to her ball-handling under pressure as a recurring issue. “Caitlin is a phenomenal talent, but those 10 turnovers are unacceptable for a player of her caliber,” McNutt said. “Against a team like the Liberty, you can’t afford to give away possessions, especially in crunch time.” McNutt emphasized that while Clark’s playmaking ability is undeniable, her decision-making in high-stakes moments needs refinement to elevate the Fever to championship contention.
This isn’t the first time McNutt has critiqued Clark. Earlier in the season, she faced backlash for downplaying Clark’s role in the Fever’s playoff push in 2024, attributing only 60% of the team’s success to her. McNutt also sparked debate by suggesting Clark’s popularity stems partly from her identity as a “white girl from the middle of America,” a comment that drew both criticism and support. Her latest remarks have further polarized fans, with some accusing her of unfairly targeting Clark, while others praise her for holding the young star accountable.
Clark, for her part, remained focused on the team’s effort. “We fought hard, but we’ve got to clean up the mistakes,” she told ESPN’s Holly Rowe, addressing the turnovers but defending her aggressive playstyle. The Fever’s championship aspirations, which Clark has openly prioritized, hinge on her ability to navigate elite defenses like the Liberty’s.
As the WNBA season progresses, McNutt’s critiques highlight the growing pains of a superstar under pressure. Whether Clark can silence her detractors with improved performances remains to be seen, but the spotlight on her every move is only intensifying.
