The sports world and music community are buzzing following a surprising and sharp critique from jazz legend Freddie Hubbard, who openly criticized the Indiana Fever and rookie sensation Caitlin Clark in a recent interview. While many were stunned to hear the 87-year-old Indianapolis native express his disapproval of Clark’s playing style, it didn’t take long for the WNBA star to respond — and with poise.
In an interview with Jazz & Culture Weekly, Hubbard reportedly commented, “The Indiana Fever? They’re a talented bunch, but they’re like a jam session gone wrong. And that girl, Caitlin Clark? She moves fast, but there’s no groove, no feeling. She’s playing basketball like it’s all technical and no soul.”
The unexpected remarks drew immediate reactions across social media, with fans defending Clark and questioning Hubbard’s take. Clark, known for her confidence and court vision, didn’t shy away when asked about the comment after Sunday’s practice at Gainbridge Fieldhouse.
“I respect legends, especially those from right here in Indiana,” Clark said. “Freddie Hubbard is a musical genius, no doubt. But when it comes to basketball — he’s way off key.”
Clark went on to say that she believes there’s actually a deep connection between music and basketball. “I play with rhythm, with emotion. That’s what makes the game beautiful — just like jazz. You can’t script every move. Sometimes you just have to feel it.”
Indiana Fever head coach Christie Sides also weighed in on the controversy, saying, “It’s unfortunate to hear a local icon speaking negatively about a young woman who’s representing this city with class and excellence. Caitlin works harder than anyone I know, and she’s brought excitement back to Indiana basketball.”
Fans, too, are rallying behind Clark. The hashtag #WayOffKey quickly trended on X (formerly Twitter), with fans remixing classic Freddie Hubbard album covers with Caitlin Clark highlights and captions like “Soul Meets Swish.”
Clark concluded her remarks with maturity beyond her years. “Look, I grew up listening to all kinds of music — jazz included. I know how much Freddie Hubbard means to this city. But I also know what I bring to the court, and that’s passion, skill, and heart. If that’s not soul, I don’t know what is.”
Though there’s been no further comment from Hubbard or his representatives, the story has stirred an unlikely conversation between fans of jazz and basketball. One thing’s clear — whether on stage or on the hardwood, rhythm matters. And Caitlin Clark has no intention of missing a beat.
About the Author
